Hey, It's kind of late notice but the Cuna Street Toy Shop is going out
of business and today is the last day.  Everything atleast 40% off and
the toys are going for cost, maybe a bit over cost.  Very cute Melissa
and Doug puzzles are $5ish, lots of playmobile, some very cute calico
critters, and lots of games/learning toys.  They have a wide variety. 
I'm very sad they're going out of business.  The toy shop is located in
the old pharmacy downtown.  It's one of the stops on the trolley tour. 
Here's my best attempt to describe how to get there:  If you're on
Anastasia Island and you go over the bridge into downtown, You'll dead
end into Flagler -take a right, When that road dead ends, turn left and
the store/parking lot is on your left (I think immediately).

Thanks Deb L!!